
Challenging negative corporate resolutions
The Ruling of the Provincial Court of Valencia, of September 24, 2024, no. 162/2024 is generally in favor of the broad admissibility of the challenge
The Provincial Court of Madrid, in judgment 132/2024 of April 23, dealt with a case in which a sole director diverted clients from one company to another, which was created for the purpose of avoiding the payment of a debt recognized by a final judgment in a previous proceeding. This act, which left the debtor company without assets, prevented the creditor from recovering its claim, even through enforcement proceedings.
Traditionally, the damages suffered by the creditors due to the reduction of the corporate assets are considered “indirect”. That is, creditors cannot claim directly against the directors, since the damage affects mainly the company as a whole, and only secondarily the creditors and shareholders. The usual remedy for these cases is the corporate liability action provided for in Article 240 of the Spanish Companies Act (LSC), the purpose of which is to restore the company’s assets. However, the Provincial Court, following the doctrine of the Supreme Court, has pointed out that, in certain qualified cases, the creditors may suffer a “direct” damage that justifies the use of the individual liability action (art. 241 LSC).
In the specific case, the Provincial Court considers that all the elements necessary to admit the individual action were present: an organic wrong was committed, direct damage was caused to the creditor and there was a clear causal link between the actions of the director and the damage suffered.
The Ruling of the Provincial Court of Valencia, of September 24, 2024, no. 162/2024 is generally in favor of the broad admissibility of the challenge
The DGSJFP has clarified that the sufficiency and equivalence judgements are the responsibility of the authorising notary in Spain. However, the judgement of equivalence does
Portugal has initiated a new stage in its international tax strategy with the implementation of IFICI, also known as RNH 2.0. This new regime seeks